In the strange, sad year of America’s Semiquincentennial, I thought a lot about the Bicentennial, a presidential election year. In 1976, the people elected a Southern Baptist—not a pulpit screecher but someone who quietly carried his own luggage. Gerald Ford’s administration planned the country’s big party, but he had pardoned Richard Nixon of any high crimes and misdemeanors. Many people voted for Jimmy Carter hoping for a return to small-town decency, the moral order of mainline Protestants.
As a Catholic schoolkid, I unconsciously otherized Protestants. They stripped away the drama of the saints but also the stained-glass and frescoed mystique of the Italian Renaissance. Once you could choose a denomination like a style of kitchen cabinet, the whole thing became an entirely human enterprise. Of course, I was already realizing the human hand in Catholic creed, but Protestants accelerated my doubting because of how their activities overlapped with all things “municipal.” Their churches provided function space for public daycare, special ed programs, AA meetings. Their basements contained dirty gym mats for tumbling and old upright pianos. These cavernous spaces smelled like damp plastic and the lost wood parts of Fisher-Price toys. Protestants constantly reminded you that you were ordinary and one of many. And there was safety and comfort to be found in a community of the ordinary (see the Book of Common Prayer, circa 1662).
Continue reading