The Republic

In the strange, sad year of America’s Semiquincentennial, I thought a lot about the Bicentennial, a presidential election year. In 1976, the people elected a Southern Baptist—not a pulpit screecher but someone who quietly carried his own luggage. Gerald Ford’s administration planned the country’s big party, but he had pardoned Richard Nixon of any high crimes and misdemeanors. Many people voted for Jimmy Carter hoping for a return to small-town decency, the moral order of mainline Protestants.

As a Catholic schoolkid, I unconsciously otherized Protestants. They stripped away the drama of the saints but also the stained-glass and frescoed mystique of the Italian Renaissance. Once you could choose a denomination like a style of kitchen cabinet, the whole thing became an entirely human enterprise. Of course, I was already realizing the human hand in Catholic creed, but Protestants accelerated my doubting because of how their activities overlapped with all things “municipal.” Their churches provided function space for public daycare, special ed programs, AA meetings. Their basements contained dirty gym mats for tumbling and old upright pianos. These cavernous spaces smelled like damp plastic and the lost wood parts of Fisher-Price toys. Protestants constantly reminded you that you were ordinary and one of many. And there was safety and comfort to be found in a community of the ordinary (see the Book of Common Prayer, circa 1662).

As an aspiring cosmopolitan, I had more interest in the world’s other religions than I did in American Protestants. I suppose I was guilty (of course I was; I was Catholic!) of following “too much the devices and desires of our own hearts,” as the Anglicans’ Morning Prayer cautioned. When in middle school I learned about Martin Luther King, Jr., and the Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta, the Dexter Avenue Baptist Church in Montgomery, and the role of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference in the civil rights movement, I developed a new idea about Protestants. They did things, they changed things, and it was I who’d been wrong in the gilded isolationism of frescoes darkened and coated by burnt candlewax.

The Christian sacrament of confirmation (whereby a semi-mature mind confirms to a congregation that, yes, this religion is my own choice and not that of my parents) is echoed in the civic responsibility of registering to vote. And while people like me will go through with confirmation when they don’t believe any of it, I like to think that far fewer of those who register to vote will never vote.

The postwar consensus that many Americans now mourn was technically a constitutional bad: tolerant, low-res Protestantism joined at the hip with democratic governing at the municipal level. Some of the reasons for the strict separation of church and state are actually drains on democracy while some of the technically illegal blurring have the opposite effect. That’s because the qualities that make someone conscientious in regard to their religion make them likewise in regard to a system of government that specifically lays out how to safely apply under the conditions of religious belief.

I have not heard a better articulator of this balance than Abdul El-Sayed, the Michigander who campaigned for the U.S. Senate by comparing skepticism about his Muslim faith to anxieties about John F. Kennedy’s faith. “I am not the Catholic candidate for president,” Kennedy proclaimed in 1960. “I am the Democratic Party’s candidate for president, who happens also to be a Catholic.” “I’m not running to be a Muslim senator,” El-Sayed echoed this fall. “I’m running for the U.S. Senate and happen to be Muslim.”

And yet even Kennedy’s own grandson, the failed congressional candidate Jack Schlossberg, got in his dig at El-Sayed: “JFK ran on policy and took questions on religion,” he tweeted. “Abdul did the opposite.” Most of the chorus of hate against El-Sayed’s campaign was not as civil. The tolerant, low-res Protestantism that buttressed town halls across America seemed to have completely disappeared, as quaint an idea as Billy Graham, the North Carolina preacher who had friendly ties with 11 consecutive U.S. presidents, Republican and Democrat. Graham’s preacher son, Franklin, is firmly entrenched as a MAGA-loving, White Christian Nationalist war monger.

This past summer, I reread Otherwise (1996), Jane Kenyon’s posthumous collection of poems selected and edited by her husband, the poet Donald Hall. One poem has stuck with me since then: part of “American Triptych, ” originally published in From Room to Room (1978), about the Wilmot, New Hampshire, community where Kenyon and Hall lived happily until her death in 1995. Reading this poem was like remembering an unremarkable dream set in the most ordinary place—and in the process realizing that the comfort bestowed by the ordinary had become an exotic pleasure, mainly because unreachable in the sad summer of loss.

But then, in the first week of November, everything changed. Everything changed (for the moment at least), and Kenyon’s poem was reborn in my mind as a rare instance of kismet. The best thing I can think to do is to reproduce it here. (And “Michigan” is just the chef’s kiss.)

Potluck at the Wilmot Flat Baptist Church

We drive to the flat on a clear November night. Stars and planets appear in the eastern sky, not yet in the west.

Voices rise from the social hall downstairs, the clink of silverware and plates, the smell of coffee.

As we walk into the room faces turn to us, friendly and curious. We are seated at the speakers’ table next to the town historian, a retired schoolteacher who is lively and precise.

The table is decorated with red, white, and blue streamers, and framed Time and Newsweek covers of the President, just elected. Someone has tied peanuts to small branches with red, white, and blue yarn, and set the branches upright in lumps of clay at the center of each table.

After the meal everyone clears food from the tables, and tables from the hall. Then we go up to the sanctuary, where my husband reads poems from the pulpit.

One woman looks out the window continually. I notice the altar cloth, tasseled and embroidered in gold thread: Til I Come. There is applause after each poem.

On the way home we pass the white clapboard faces of the library and town hall, luminous in the moonlight, and I remember the first time I ever voted——in a township hall in Michigan.

The same wonderful smell of coffee was in the air, and I found myself among people trying to live ordered lives . . . And again I am struck with love for the Republic.